Wawa: Indianapolis, IN 3835 E 96th St 5,915 SF Retail Building Indianapolis, IN 46240 $4,500,000 ($760.78/SF) 4.78% Cap Rate



INVESTMENT HIGHLIGHTS
- This location is Wawa’s first store in Indiana. The company has plans to build a total of 10 Indiana stores in 2025.
- Roughly 11 miles northeast of downtown Indianapolis, Wawa is positioned at the roundabout intersection of East 96th Street (31,216 VPD).
- Wawa is located within the Keystone submarket of Indianapolis—an amenity-rich area known for its high-end retail and modern office spaces.
- Wawa’s absolute NNN ground lease will feature a corporate guaranty from Wawa, Inc. and 20 years of primary term.
- Wawa is within a 1-mile radius of over a dozen new and used car dealerships and collision centers.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
CBRE is pleased to exclusively offer for sale a 20-year absolute NNN Wawa ground lease situated on 1.91 acres within the Keystone Crossing retail submarket of Indianapolis, IN (MSA population: 2.17M+). Currently under construction, the 5,915-square-foot store is expected to open in May 2025, signaling Wawa’s largest expansion starting with ±10 stores in each of Indiana, Ohio and Kentucky this year. The company has plans to open 160 stores in these three states over the next five to eight years. The lease will feature a guaranty from Wawa, Inc. as well as a 7.5% rent increase every 5 years throughout the initial term and in each of the six, 5-year renewal options.
PROPERTY FACTS
Sale Type
Investment NNN
Property Type
Retail
Property Subtype
Convenience Store
Building Size
5,915 SF
Building Class
B
Year Built
2025
Price
$4,500,000
Price Per SF
$760.78
Cap Rate
4.78%
NOI
$215,000
Tenancy
Single
Building Height
1 Story
Building FAR
0.07
Lot Size
1.91 AC
Zoning
C-3 - Commercial District
Parking
59 Spaces (9.97 Spaces per 1,000 SF Leased)
Frontage
344’ on E 96th St
NEARBY MAJOR RETAILERS










PROPERTY TAXES
Parcel Number | 49-02-17-114-080.000-800 | Improvements Assessment | $86,700 |
Land Assessment | $1,138,500 | Total Assessment | $1,225,200 |