54 N Chestnut St

This is a great fully leased mixed-use building in the heart of New Paltz. The property includes two ground-floor commercial units, leased to an engineer and a health care provider. Each have 5% annual rent increases in their leases. The rear portion of the ground floor is a 1BR apartment, leased through May 2025. The entire second floor is a 4BR apartment, also leased through May 2025. The upstairs 4BR tenants pay their own electric, heating oil, and hot water. The 3 downstairs units are in the process of being separately metered, with new mini-splits installed this year in the rear apartment. New meter pans and sub panels have also been installed, though they are not yet wired up. There is ample on-site parking behind the building, with 10 parking spaces. The property's B2 zoning was recently changed to allow higher density, so the existing rear 2-story garage could likely be converted or demolished/rebuilt to create additional residential units - a major source of potential upside. The property currently delivers an attractive 8.1% cap rate, even before the individual utility metering is completed and the potential future expansion is undertaken. Great location on high-visibility North Chestnut Street (Rt. 32 N), three blocks north of Main Street. Five minute walk to center of town and 10 minute walk to SUNY campus. Perfect mid-sized New Paltz mixed-use investment opportunity! Financials available upon request.