37 Fire Island Blvd
Fire Island Pines, NY 11782
Retail For Sale · Retail Property For Sale · 27,756 SF

Muroff Hospitality Group is proud to present on an exclusive basis the sale of approximately 75% of the commercial district of the Fire Island Pines Resort, a world-renowned waterfront resort complex located 90 minutes from New York City.

The Pines is the location of the most expensive real estate on Fire Island and has evolved into the best-known, wealthiest, upscale gay community in the world. It serves as the premier gay resort destination with over 600 homes. The investment includes a nightclub, a hotel, two restaurants, a pool deck, boat docks, and other retail and operating assets stretching 320 feet of the main pedestrian promenade.

Located on southern Long Island, 60 miles east of Manhattan, the property spans the main pedestrian promenade to the residential and beach access areas in the only commercial portion of the Pines. The car-free environment is a big part of Fire Island’s charm, where cars are prohibited on the residential part of the island. The most common form of transportation is parking at one of three ferry terminals and taking a delightful half-hour ferry ride across the Great South Bay in the fresh, salty air.

The resort occupies an irreplaceable location on the harbor and in the business district where no other available or developable commercial parcels exist. Comprising 75% of the only commercially zoned region in the Pines, the resort offers the only zoned hotel within the Pines community. The property provides an opportunity to acquire two adjacent parcels to add 18-24 rooms to the hotel. Existing businesses generate stabilized revenues with 320 feet of boat slips, providing additional opportunities for upside and income. Reimagining the hotel and marketing offers enormous potential to increase RevPAR. Plus, events and improved utilization rate for the pavilion complex provide considerable upside.